ACLU: Some families separated in Trump’s first term now detained again
A recent class action lawsuit filed by the ACLU claims that the Trump Administration has not complied with a settlement agreement reached in 2023 concerning the separation of families at the U.S.-Mexico border. The ACLU argues that at least 25 individuals who were previously separated from their families during the prior administration have been detained again or deported.
The family separations were initially part of President Donald Trump’s “zero-tolerance” policy, which aimed to discourage migrants from entering the U.S., including those seeking asylum. The ACLU filed the lawsuit on behalf of a woman who was separated from her daughter after arriving at the San Ysidro port of entry in 2017 to seek asylum. This case was later expanded to cover any parents or children who were separated during Trump’s first term.
When the lawsuit was filed, the ACLU believed there were only a few hundred families affected, but they later discovered it was closer to 6,000 families that were separated. The Biden Administration, upon taking office, reached a settlement agreement in 2023 to address the family separations and offer assistance to those impacted. Attorney General Merrick Garland condemned the practice of family separations as “shameful.”
Under the settlement agreement, efforts were made to reunify families, provide legal support, and allow individuals to apply for parole while awaiting resolution of their asylum cases. However, the ACLU now alleges that at least 25 individuals have been detained or deported despite having valid parole status. The government maintains that these removals were lawful and in compliance with the settlement agreement.
Immigration attorney Narciso Cruz, who represented parents separated from their children, described the chaos and hardship faced by families during the separation process. Many parents were distraught, seeking immediate deportation to be with their children or desperately trying to locate their children. The lack of communication and organization within the system resulted in further trauma for children and families affected by the separations.
According to Cruz, representing a 5-year-old child in these circumstances was particularly challenging due to the confusion and emotional toll experienced by the children. The trauma caused by the separation policy continues to impact these families, highlighting the long-term consequences of the harsh immigration enforcement measures implemented during Trump’s administration. The ACLU’s ongoing efforts to ensure compliance with the settlement agreement underscore the urgent need to address the human rights violations that occurred during this period.