Executive Order focuses on proxy advisory firms: ERISA implications highlighted

President Trump signed an executive order on December 11, 2025, targeting the prominent proxy advisory firms ISS and Glass Lewis. The order highlights the firms’ alleged prioritization of political agendas like diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) and environmental, social, and governance (ESG) initiatives over investor profitability. In response, the order instructed the US Department of Labor (D0L) and other agencies to take specific actions, potentially leading to significant implications for fiduciaries of ERISA plans.

Although the executive order itself does not immediately alter any regulations or laws, it signifies increased federal scrutiny and potential future regulatory changes by bodies such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), Federal Trade Commission (FTC), and the Department of Labor (DOL). The primary directives issued include:

1. The SEC was tasked with reviewing and potentially amending all regulations and guidance related to shareholder proposals, like Rule 14a-8, to ensure they align with the order’s focus on prioritizing investor returns over political objectives.

2. The SEC was also instructed to explore measures to enhance supervision of proxy advisors. This includes cracking down on deceptive voting recommendations, contemplating the requirement for proxy advisors to register as investment advisors, enhancing transparency regarding methodologies and conflicts of interest, and evaluating the necessity of third-party validation of proxy advisor recommendations.

This action reflects the government’s concerns about proxy advisory firms potentially wielding influential power over corporate voting decisions. By emphasizing the importance of safeguarding investor interests and financial returns, the order seeks to address alleged practices that prioritize social and political objectives at the expense of investor profitability.

The implications of this executive order have sparked discussions in the investment and regulatory landscapes, highlighting the need for greater transparency and accountability within the proxy advisory industry. Fiduciaries of ERISA plans may need to reassess their approach to engaging with proxy advisory firms and ensure that their investment decisions align with the best interests of plan participants and beneficiaries.

Overall, the executive order targeting proxy advisory firms underscores the government’s commitment to promoting investor protection and reinforcing the integrity of capital markets. It remains to be seen how regulatory bodies will interpret and implement these directives, but it is clear that the order has set the stage for potential changes in how proxy advisors operate and interact with institutional investors in the future.