Will Mandatory Arbitration Lead to the Decline of Securities Class Actions?
Could Mandatory Arbitration Impact Securities Class Actions?
The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) recently made a significant change in its policy regarding the presence of mandatory arbitration clauses in a company’s governing documents. On September 17, 2025, the SEC announced that the existence of a mandatory arbitration provision would no longer affect the agency’s decisions on approving the effectiveness of a securities registration statement.
Traditionally, the SEC maintained that mandatory arbitration provisions could potentially violate federal securities laws by impeding investors from seeking redress in courts, such as through class actions. However, the SEC now believes that federal securities laws do not ensure the right to pursue claims in court or on a classwide basis. SEC Chairman Paul S. Atkins hailed this change as a step towards improving initial public offerings (IPOs).
Implementation of arbitration agreements that require shareholders to pursue claims individually rather than through class actions may help tackle issues within the class action mechanism. Expensive legal defenses against claims from numerous shareholders and the risk of significant damages can push companies towards settlements, even in cases of meritless claims.
Despite the change in SEC policy, there are various factors for companies to consider when deciding whether to adopt mandatory arbitration clauses. Legal hurdles might emerge, with state laws potentially hindering the enforcement of arbitration provisions in a corporation’s charter or bylaws. Furthermore, SEC Commissioner Caroline Crenshaw cautioned that extremely restrictive provisions in shareholder claims might still conflict with Supreme Court rulings. Some legal experts speculate that companies opting for mandatory arbitration could face legal challenges.
Public companies must also weigh the opinions of investors and proxy advisory firms. While some shareholders oppose mandatory arbitration, others are attracted to avoiding the costs and distractions of shareholder litigation. Moreover, there are procedural benefits to litigating in court, including the safeguards provided by the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, which impose stricter requirements on plaintiffs in securities cases.
Courts handling securities class actions have dismissed cases at a high rate, showcasing the challenges plaintiffs face. Classwide settlements in court offer comprehensive solutions, while defending multiple arbitrations could be costly for companies. The decision on whether to opt for arbitration or court litigation depends on various factors, including investor sentiments and potential claims against the company.
Beyond legal considerations, companies must evaluate how arbitration findings could impact insurance coverage and indemnities. Crafting arbitration provisions that extend to other parties seeking indemnification is crucial to avoid class action liabilities indirectly.
In conclusion, while the SEC’s policy change may pave the way for enhancing shareholder protection, the decision to adopt mandatory arbitration clauses is not straightforward. Companies should conduct thorough analyses of the factors and undertake a cost-benefit assessment to make informed decisions tailored to their specific circumstances. Each organization must carefully weigh the implications of adopting mandatory arbitration provisions to navigate the complexities of shareholder litigation effectively.