Effective Ways for Government to Reduce Emission Disclosure and Reporting Burdens
The landscape of carbon accounting, disclosure, and reporting is experiencing significant shifts. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has put forth a proposal to remove the Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program (GHGRP), while the Greenhouse Gas Protocol (GHGP) is currently undergoing a public consultation phase to update its methodologies. Private firms are also introducing alternatives to the GHGP, like Carbon Measures, to enhance carbon accounting tools. Foreign governments are stepping in with carbon border adjustments (CBAM) imposing greenhouse gas (GHG) measuring requirements on imported firms. California is extending reporting and disclosure mandates for entities within the state. As these developments unfold, discussions around the most appropriate policy responses have surfaced, with emphasis on the policies governments should steer clear of.
The debate around the value of emission-related information is a focal point in this arena. Some contend that such information holds little worth, with claims that it does not significantly impact firms’ profitability or policy alterations. This viewpoint is embodied in the Trump administration’s move to repeal the GHGRP. Conversely, others stress the critical value of emission data, particularly in light of the rise in emission-controlling policies. The idea of “transition risk” emerges, suggesting that entities with high emissions face financial losses as the world shifts towards cleaner energy. The SEC under the Biden administration proposed climate disclosure requirements in 2022, linking emissions to financial risk. The SEC argued that emissions data was material information that companies must divulge to fulfill their fiduciary duties.
At R Street, we assert that the truth lies somewhere between these extremes. While some firms face considerable risks from emission-controlling policies or transition risks, not all emissions create financial vulnerabilities. Emission sources vary in their exposure to controlling policies, with some even benefiting from such regulations. The private sector values emission-related data, with certain firms leveraging emission disclosure to boost profitability. However, government interventions could devalue emissions information by introducing excessive reporting burdens or demanding disclosure of financially immaterial data that lessens the value of material information.
Determining the relevance of emission-related information to investors and devising optimal reporting methods largely falls within the domain of the private sector. Exceptional cases arise when external entities like foreign governments or states impose burdensome reporting schemes, causing misinformation that hampers capital allocation efficiency. The flawed approach by the SEC under Biden sought burdensome reporting and disclosure requirements, lacking utility for investors.
Government should acknowledge that it is not their role to supplant private sector efforts in discerning optimal emission-related information production and utilization methods. The failed SEC disclosure requirements highlighted unintended consequences of governmental interventions. For instance, the proposed SEC rule penalized firms for engaging in emission abatement efforts and mandated disclosure of ambiguous “scope 3” emissions, escalating reporting burdens. These regulations could discourage firms from investments valued by eco-conscious consumers, ultimately leading to poor capital allocation. Complete government retreat on emissions reporting also poses risks, necessitating a balanced approach. In essence, finding the balance between governmental involvement and private sector initiatives is crucial for efficient and valuable emission reporting and disclosure practices.