Diageo seeks dismissal of Tequila class action

Diageo, the owner of Don Julio, is currently facing legal action in the form of a class action lawsuit that challenges the marketing claims made by the Tequila brand. The lawsuit alleges that Don Julio and Casamigos, both owned by Diageo, contain non-agave alcohol, contrary to what is stated on their labels. This legal battle began in May when consumers and a restaurant filed a lawsuit against Diageo in New York, followed by similar cases in California and Florida.

In response to these allegations, Diageo has filed a motion to dismiss all the lawsuits, claiming that the accusations are baseless and lack any legal or logical foundation. The company maintains that its Tequilas are indeed made from 100% Blue Weber agave, as stated on the labels of Don Julio and Casamigos. Diageo argues that the testing conducted by the plaintiffs is scientifically unvalidated and unreliable, akin to claiming that the earth is flat based on misleading evidence.

The plaintiffs’ case hinges on the results of a single test conducted by a European company, which Diageo deems insufficient and inconclusive due to its unproven methodology. The company highlights the stringent production process it follows in the making of its Tequilas and points out that its labeling complies with the regulations set by the Consejo Regulador del Tequila (CRT) in Mexico and US laws.

Moreover, Diageo asserts that the plaintiffs lack any substantial evidence to support their claims of deception within the Tequila industry, as the allegations are primarily based on blog posts and unsubstantiated statements. The company contends that the plaintiffs’ attempt to weave a narrative of massive deception involving multiple brands, facilities, and regulatory bodies is unfounded and lacks factual basis.

The issue of transparency in the Tequila industry and the presence of additives has been a contentious topic, with other companies like Bacardi and the CRT engaging in discussions to address concerns regarding transparency and the use of additives in Tequila production. The Additive Free Alliance has also faced legal action from the CRT for its claims about which Tequila brands are considered additive-free.

In conclusion, the legal battle between Diageo and the plaintiffs underscores the importance of transparency and compliance with regulations in the spirits industry. As the motion to dismiss the lawsuits unfolds, the outcome will shed light on the complexities surrounding the marketing and production practices of Tequila brands like Don Julio and Casamigos.