Controversy arises over SECP’s generous salary increase
Controversy has arisen regarding a substantial pay increase approved by the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan’s (SECP) Policy Board, as sources revealed that there was not complete agreement on the decision. During a meeting in November 2024, private sector member Shagufta Shamsuddin Hassan raised concerns over the unequal salary adjustments and advocated for a uniform 15% raise for all employees. However, the SECP’s proposal outlined more substantial increases for executives, such as executive directors, compared to joint directors and junior staff, causing discontent within the organization.
Despite objections from some members, the board proceeded to approve the revamped salaries with a minimum quorum present. Notably, the commerce secretary was absent from the meeting and was represented by an additional secretary, prompting doubts about the transparency of the approval process. The situation escalated further when the Auditor General of Pakistan highlighted the significant allowances granted, totaling Rs226 million for salary adjustments and perks, and an additional Rs111 million allocated for “rest and recreation” expenses in the annual report. Consequently, this issue has been referred to both the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) and the Senate Standing Committee on Finance and Revenue for review.
Following media scrutiny regarding the generous perks given to commissioners and the chairman, the SECP dispatched a team to Karachi to meet with Hassan and address her grievances. The team reportedly spent three days trying to dissuade her from escalating the matter any further. Legal experts have also questioned the authority of the Policy Board to revise the salaries of the chairman and commissioners, as they are appointed by the federal government and not considered regular SECP employees.
The controversy has drawn attention to the SECP, with lawmakers seeking clarifications on the legality and equity of the unprecedented salary increase. In response to inquiries, an SECP spokesperson maintained that the Policy Board’s decision on the pay raises was unanimous. The spokesperson explained that a standardized formula, based on an independent market survey, was utilized to determine the adjustments, irrespective of seniority levels. The market benchmark percentile for senior positions was reportedly lower than that for junior positions, indicating a consistent approach to salary adjustments.
Overall, the dissent over the SECP’s salary revisions has brought into question the transparency and fairness of the decision-making process, leading to increased scrutiny from regulatory bodies and public officials. The ongoing discussions surrounding this issue highlight the importance of accountability and governance within organizations overseeing financial matters.