FCC Diversity Ruling vs. Station Employee Data Collections: No Comparison

Advocates pushing back against a new rule that would mandate radio and TV stations to gather data on their employees’ race, ethnicity, and gender and send it to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) are finding reasons for hope in a recent court decision. However, FCC attorneys are quick to point out that this decision is not directly related to the FCC case and should not influence the outcome.

The American Family Association and National Religious Broadcasters, who are at the forefront of opposing the FCC’s decision to reinstate this requirement, are drawing parallels between a recent ruling from the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals and their fight against the FCC. The court ruled that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) overstepped its bounds by attempting to make public companies disclose information about the diversity of their boards.

In response to this ruling, the broadcast groups are arguing that the FCC is similarly overreaching in its attempt to compel broadcasters to report their workforce demographics. They claim that the FCC is venturing beyond its usual regulatory scope and trying to enforce diversity objectives that they are not authorized to enforce.

On the other hand, FCC lawyers are steadfast in their belief that the FCC’s new rules are distinct from what the SEC proposed. They emphasize that the data collected under these rules will solely be used for monitoring and reporting on industry trends, and not for implementing diversity targets like the SEC required. The FCC asserts that they have explicit statutory authority to collect this data, as outlined in the Communications Act.

Despite the ongoing legal challenge, the FCC has postponed the filing of Form 395-B for this year due to finalizing the new form and instructions, not because of the lawsuit. The fate of these new rules remains uncertain, especially with potential leadership changes on the horizon that could potentially reverse the decision.

Oral arguments are set to take place in early February 2025, where the fate of these rules will likely be decided. Whether the FCC will be able to enforce these regulations or if they will be struck down remains to be seen, but the battle is far from over.