SCOTUS November 2024: Quick Snapshot and Analysis
Facebook’s attempt to get the Supreme Court to throw out a private securities fraud case against them hit a roadblock when the justices admitted they made a mistake in hearing the case. Investors, including Amalgamated Bank, claim that Facebook deceived them regarding Cambridge Analytica’s inappropriate access to data from 30 million users. The case is known as Facebook Inc. v. Amalgamated Bank.
Nvidia Corp. faced a lawsuit from shareholders who accused the company of downplaying the significance of cryptocurrency mining customers. They presented their preferred standards for private securities fraud lawsuits to the Supreme Court. The justices not only questioned the specificity of the claims but also debated whether the case was suitable for review at the highest court. This case is referred to as Nvidia Corp. v. E. Ohman J:Or Fonder AB.
In a different case involving the Fair Labor Standards Act exemptions, the Supreme Court explored the necessity for a higher burden of proof when it comes to overtime wage protections. A grocery store challenged the heightened burden imposed by the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in the case E.M.D. Sales v. Carrera.
Turning now to certiorari proceedings, the Supreme Court is seeking input from the federal government in a copyright infringement dispute between Cox Communications Inc. and Sony Music Entertainment. The case revolves around the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decision that found Cox liable for not doing enough to prevent music piracy and overturned a large damages award. This case is significant and is known as Cox Communications Inc. v. Sony Music Entertainment.
The Supreme Court will also weigh in on the constitutionality of the Federal Communication Commission’s Universal Service Fund, which provides phone and internet access to various groups. Critics argue that the fund violates the nondelegation doctrine by giving the FCC authority to raise revenue. This case is Federal Communications Commission v. Consumers’ Research.
Board members of a Pentecostal college have requested the Supreme Court’s involvement in a lawsuit concerning religious requirements for university leadership. They claim that allowing Presbyterian board members to serve violates the First Amendment and the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine, which prohibits courts from interfering in religious matters. This case is Bethesda University v. Cho.
Lastly, in the realm of original jurisdiction cases, the federal government has urged the Supreme Court to reject Utah’s attempt to use a proceeding to gain control over 18.5 million acres managed by the Bureau of Land Management. The government argues that Utah’s claims should be addressed in lower federal courts. This case is known as Utah v. United States.