Antitrust regulator to assess challenge to United’s stake in Azul

as de Lima approving IPSConsumo’s admission as a third party in the ongoing case. This comes after United Airlines and American Airlines agreed to each invest $100 million in the Brazilian carrier as part of Azul’s restructuring process under Chapter 11 in the United States.

IPSConsumo’s appeal will now undergo thorough scrutiny by CADE’s commissioners in an upcoming session scheduled for February 11. If accepted, the tribunal will conduct a more in-depth review with a deadline of up to 330 days. Commissioner Diogo Thomson de Andrade has been appointed as the rapporteur for this appeal, with sources suggesting that the decision may work against Azul, as some commissioners tend to recognize third-party appeals and examine cases more thoroughly.

The uncertainty surrounding United’s investment in Azul comes at a crucial time for the airline, which is currently under court-supervised restructuring in the United States. Despite a favorable opinion from CADE’s General Superintendence on United’s investment, IPSConsumo raised objections citing potential harm to competition. The institute argued that United Airlines’ minority stake in Azul’s controlling group, coupled with its stake in the holding company Abra, which controls Gol and Avianca, could lead to the exchange of competitively sensitive information and coordinated conduct among competitors.

IPSConsumo also highlighted concerns about changes to Azul’s bylaws, including the creation of a new Strategic Committee that would grant United Airlines special powers to influence operational decisions and elevate them to the status of a strategic partner. In response, CADE’s president emphasized that the decision to admit IPSConsumo as a third party was preliminary and aimed at forwarding the appeal to a tribunal member for further review.

Juliana Pereira, president of IPSConsumo, emphasized the importance of respecting Brazil’s competition authority, stating that the transaction between United and Azul was presented as a simple minority investment without a comprehensive analysis of its impacts on competition. Azul and United Airlines have not yet provided comments on the matter, leaving the final decision in the hands of CADE’s tribunal as they navigate the complex landscape of antitrust regulations in Brazil.