SEC Drops Cyber Disclosure Case Against SolarWinds and CISO
On December 4, 2025, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission made a significant announcement regarding the dismissal of a civil enforcement lawsuit against SolarWinds Corporation (SolarWinds) and its chief information security officer (CISO). The case, known as Securities and Exchange Commission v. SolarWinds Corp. and Timothy G. Brown, No. 1:23-cv-09518-PAE, filed on October 30, 2023, had stirred much attention in the business world. The lawsuit had the potential to set a precedent for companies dealing with cybersecurity risks, as it explored the complexities of responding to, investigating, and disclosing cyber threats effectively.
SolarWinds, a firm offering IT management software, faced a major cybersecurity incident in December 2020 when it detected a compromise in its network monitoring tool, Orion Software Platform. This attack, dubbed SUNBURST, was engineered by Russian agents to infiltrate SolarWinds’s supply chain and target its customers. By injecting malicious code into Orion software updates, the attackers exploited approximately 18,000 customers, including the U.S. government. The severity of the breach prompted the Department of Homeland Security’s Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) to issue an emergency directive to mitigate the risks posed by the attack.
SolarWinds responded swiftly to the cyber incident, with its CEO being alerted to a security vulnerability in Orion on December 12, 2020. The following day, the company urged customers through social media to upgrade their Orion software. Subsequently, SolarWinds officially disclosed the cyberattack and initiated an investigation through regulatory filings. The company continued to provide additional details about the breach and its response measures, demonstrating transparency in its communications.
The SEC’s legal action against SolarWinds revolved around allegations regarding misleading statements made by the company and its CISO pertaining to cybersecurity practices before the attack. The SEC also argued that the subsequent disclosures about the breach were misleading. While most of the SEC’s claims were dismissed in July 2024, some allegations concerning the accuracy of SolarWinds’s cybersecurity disclosures were upheld. A settlement agreement was reached between the parties, leading to the dismissal of the case in November 2025.
The SolarWinds case has had a profound impact on the discussion surrounding the materiality of cybersecurity incidents, particularly in the context of public company disclosures. The SEC’s enforcement action highlighted the importance of accurately representing cybersecurity risks to investors, aligning with its rules implemented in July 2023. Additionally, subsequent charges against other firms related to cybersecurity disclosures during the SolarWinds attack underscored the significance of transparent communication in such situations.
The SEC’s decision to dismiss the SolarWinds case reflects a broader shift in the agency’s enforcement priorities towards a more traditional approach. The case, which targeted the CISO and expanded disclosure liability for cybersecurity risks, drew attention to internal communications as evidence of awareness of cybersecurity vulnerabilities. While this dismissal may signal a retreat from innovative enforcement strategies in cybersecurity cases, it does not diminish the importance of maintaining vigilance and ensuring adequate disclosures in cybersecurity incidents for the protection of investors and the integrity of public markets.