Peter Rahal and David Protein of Epogee are facing a lawsuit over their star ingredient
In a recent legal development, Peter Rahal and David Protein are facing a lawsuit over allegations of a ‘bait & switch’ plan to monopolize Epogee’s innovative fat replacement technology. This technology, known as EPG, was a key component in David’s protein bars before the acquisition of Epogee. The lawsuit, filed in New York against Peter Rahal, Linus Technology (doing business as David Protein), and Epogee, was brought forth by food companies including OWN Your Hunger, Lighten Up Foods, and Defiant Foods. They claim that the defendants engaged in anticompetitive behavior by acquiring Epogee through secretive methods and then using their control over EPG to create a monopoly and exclude competitors.
It is alleged that after Epogee announced shortages of certain types of EPG in March, they reassured customers that supplies would be available by May. However, on May 29, Epogee informed clients that they would no longer accept new orders and that David had secured all EPG capacity for the next two years to prevent competitors from accessing it. This move, according to the plaintiffs, led to significant disruptions in their operations and lost sales. They argue that David and Epogee engaged in a deliberate scheme to eliminate brands that had invested heavily in EPG and had structured their businesses around this unique ingredient.
The plaintiffs assert that at least five additional food manufacturing businesses, in addition to themselves, are experiencing or planning layoffs, product discontinuations, and closures due to the unavailability of EPG. They are seeking a temporary restraining order to prevent David from restricting access to EPG for existing customers and qualified food manufacturers. Ruz Safai, founder of OWN Your Hunger, highlighted the importance of EPG in their product formulations and expressed disappointment at being cut off from their supply after the acquisition.
Blake Sanburg, from Lighten Up Foods, shared his experience of investing time and resources in developing a product using EPG, only to be denied access by Epogee after the acquisition. This sudden turn of events has left him without a viable alternative and jeopardized the future of his product, which was centered around the unique properties of EPG.
EPG, short for esterified propoxylated glycerol, is created by modifying plant-based oils such as canola to reduce its caloric content drastically. Unlike traditional fats, EPG is resistant to lipase, an enzyme that breaks down fat in the body, resulting in fewer released calories per gram. This technology appealed to David as it aligned with their goal of reducing fat and carbohydrate content in their protein bars. Unlike previous fat substitutes like Olestra, EPG functions like fat without messy side effects, making it an attractive option for food manufacturers.
The lawsuit highlights the anticompetitive practices allegedly employed by Peter Rahal and David Protein in acquiring Epogee and controlling access to EPG. The plaintiffs are seeking legal recourse to address the impact of these actions on their businesses and the broader food industry.