Texans fans with PSLs file lawsuit against Houston Texans for fraud and breach of contract

A recent lawsuit filed by 19 Permanent Seat License (PSL) holders against the Houston Texans alleges fraud, breach of contract, and violations of the Texas Free Enterprise Act. The plaintiffs claim that the NFL franchise engaged in discriminatory ticket pricing practices and market manipulation, impacting not only them but also countless other Texans fans.

The lawsuit contends that the Texans abruptly changed their longstanding business practices in 2024, leading to significant disparities in pricing for PSL holders. While previously assuring equal treatment for all PSL holders, the team reportedly charged the plaintiffs up to 15% more for season tickets compared to other holders with similar tenure. This sudden pricing shift left the plaintiffs feeling unfairly targeted and misled by the team, causing financial harm and frustration among loyal fans who simply wanted to attend games at NRG Stadium.

Furthermore, the lawsuit accuses the Texans of selectively withholding invoices from the plaintiffs and categorizing their tickets as “new” season ticket pricing, despite publicly promoting competitive pricing for all tenured PSL holders. This reclassification was seen as discriminatory and purposefully designed to compel the plaintiffs to relinquish their PSLs in favor of reselling them at higher prices. The plaintiffs expressed deep disappointment in how they were once valued by the team, now seemingly abandoned in the pursuit of increased profits and ticket sales.

Seeking at least $1 million in damages, the plaintiffs also emphasized the potential for triple damages under Texas law should liability be established. In addition to financial compensation, they are requesting interest, attorney’s fees, and other legal expenses incurred throughout the course of the lawsuit.

Key allegations within the lawsuit include claims of discriminatory pricing, revocation of tenured status for season ticket members, market manipulation through restricted competition, and retaliation against resellers who participate in secondary ticket platforms. The plaintiffs argue that the Texans’ actions not only violate contractual agreements but also undermine economic competition, harm consumers by inflating ticket prices, and limit access to games for dedicated fans.

This legal battle sheds light on the complexities of sports franchises’ handling of ticket sales, pricing structures, and customer relationships. It underscores the significant impact such decisions can have on loyal fans and the importance of transparent and fair business practices within the sports industry. The outcome of this lawsuit could have lasting implications for how teams engage with their fan base and the broader consumer market.