District 20 teacher faces 207 felony charges

A Colorado Springs District 20 teacher, Nicolle Lewis-McTague, is facing a staggering 207 charges of securities fraud, forgery, and impersonation related to a complex scheme tied to the real estate business she co-established with her former spouse. Lewis-McTague allegedly accrued close to $3,000,000 in loans between 2019 and 2022 through a series of forged signatures on loans for numerous properties, facilitating cash-out refinances.

Court documents revealed that Lewis-McTague collaborated with a notary public, who played a crucial role in aiding her in committing these fraudulent activities. Investigators labeled the notary as being “instrumental” in the conspiracy, which revolved around securities fraud, forgery, and the creation of false records for financial transactions.

Despite these serious allegations, Academy District 20 officials clarified that the charges brought against Lewis-McTague are unrelated to her teaching responsibilities. The school district emphasized that she is currently on administrative leave with pay until the legal proceedings are finalized. While Lewis-McTague’s legal troubles are not directly linked to her position as an educator, the district reiterated its unwavering commitment to maintaining the highest standards of conduct among its staff members to ensure a safe and conducive academic environment for all students.

This is not the first time Lewis-McTague has faced legal repercussions. In September 2024, she admitted guilt to various charges, including theft, resulting in a sentence of three months of probation under supervision, 100 hours of community service, and a restitution payment exceeding $13,000. 11 News has attempted to reach out to Lewis-McTague for a response to these recent developments and will provide updates as the situation evolves.